,

Smiling to Death: The Hidden Dangers of Being ‘Nice’

We can learn to bring more awareness to our own emotions and needs.


KEY POINTS
Pushing down anger, prioritizing duty, and trying not to disappoint others are leading causes of chronic illness.
Ignoring or suppressing how we feel and what we need revs up our stress response, pushing our body toward inflammation.
Our need to maintain membership in our groups leads us to suppress our emotions in a tug-of-war between attachment and authenticity.

Being nice and pleasing others—while socially applauded and generally acknowledged as positive traits—actually can harm our health, says Gabor Maté.Decades of research point to the same conclusion: Pushing down our anger, prioritizing duty and the needs of others before our own, and trying not to disappoint others are leading causes of chronic illness, says the author of the New York Times bestseller, The Myth of Normal: Trauma, Illness and Healing in a Toxic Culture.

“Our physiology is inseparable from our social existence,” argues the Vancouver physician. Ignoring or suppressing how we feel and what we need—whether done consciously or unconsciously—revs up our stress response, pushing our body toward inflammation, at the cost of our immune system, he says.

“If we work our fingers to the bone, if we’re up all night serving our clients, if we’re always available, never taking time for ourselves, we’re rewarded financially and we’re rewarded with a lot of respect and admiration,” says Maté, “and we’re killing ourselves in the process.”

Personality Features of People With Chronic Illness
When Maté reviewed the research on the chronic illnesses he’d treated for more than 30 years, he discovered a pattern of personality features that most frequently present in people with chronic illness:

Automatic and compulsive concern for the emotional needs of others, while ignoring one’s own needs;
Rigid identification with social role, duty, and responsibility;
Overdriven, externally focused hyperresponsibility, based on the conviction that one must justify one’s existence by doing and giving;
Repression of healthy, self-protective anger; and
Harbouring and compulsively acting out two beliefs: I am responsible for how other people feel, and I must never disappoint anyone.
“Why these features and their striking prevalence in the personalities of chronically ill people are so often overlooked—or missed entirely,” is because they are among the “most normalized ways of being in this culture…largely by being regarded as admirable strengths rather than potential liabilities,” says Maté.
These characteristics have nothing to do with will or conscious choice, says Maté.
Coping Patterns
“No one wakes up in the morning and decides, ‘Today, I’ll put the needs of the whole world foremost, disregarding my own,’ or ‘I can’t wait to stuff down my anger and frustration and put on a happy face instead.’” Nor are we born with these traits—instead, they are coping patterns, adaptations to preserve our connection to others, sometimes at the expense of our very lives, he warns.

We develop these traits to be accepted, in what Maté describes as the tug-of-war between our competing needs for attachment and authenticity. We need attachment to survive, as we are a tribal species, wired for connection, conforming to the needs and rules of others to secure our membership in groups.

But we also need authenticity to keep us healthy. We’re designed to feel and act on emotions, especially the “negative” ones. It’s our alarm system to survive danger. Psychiatrist Randolph Nesse, founding director of the Centre for Evolution and Medicine at Arizona State University, explains that we’ve evolved to survive, not to be happy or calm.

Low mood, anger, shame, anxiety, guilt, grief—these are all helpful responses to help us meet the challenges of our specific environments. Having loud, sensitive protective functions like emotions that sound alarms when we’re threatened isn’t a design flaw. It’s a design success.

Our emotions act as smoke alarms to match the perceived threats around us, says Nesse. This seems most obvious with emotions, like fear, that scream out warnings of danger. But even more subtle emotional experiences help us navigate threats and rewards for survival. The discomfort of a low mood is signaling that there aren’t enough rewards in our environment to outweigh the risks of being there, motivating us to seek out circumstances that are more rewarding or conserve our energy in a safe place—like in bed bingeing Netflix—until the rewards return.
Anger, too, is a necessary response to fight inequities, violations, and having our needs blocked. It’s our most effective tool to mobilize action against injustice. The biggest obstacle to social justice is not heated opposition, but apathy. And, yet, society has socialized many of us to suppress anger. Even the vilified emotion of anger’s more subtle form, resentment, is helpful. When our body and brain pick up subtle cues that our boundaries are not being respected, the resentment alarm shouts out loud and clear to assert these boundaries before we even have time to reflect on the situation.

Suppressing Vital Emotions
Yet, the need to maintain membership in our groups has led us to suppress these vital emotional signals, disarming our ability to protect ourselves, says Maté. Even more problematic, says Maté, is that conscious suppression of emotions has been shown to heighten our stress response and lead to poor health outcomes. “We know that chronic stress, whatever its source, puts the nervous system on edge, distorts the hormonal apparatus, impairs immunity, promotes inflammation, and undermines physical and mental well-being,” says Maté. And numerous studies show that a body stuck in a chronic stress response stays in an inflamed state, Maté continues, the precursor of many chronic illnesses, such as heart disease, cancer, autoimmune diseases, Alzheimer’s, depression, and many others.

Maté is careful not to use this research to blame people for their own illnesses. “No person is their disease, and no one did it to themselves—not in any conscious, deliberate or culpable sense,” he says. “Disease is an outcome of generations of suffering, of social conditions, of cultural conditioning, of childhood trauma, of physiology bearing the brunt of peoples stresses and emotional histories, all interacting with the physical and psychological environment. It is often manifestations of ingrained personality traits, yes—but that personality is not who we are any more than are the illnesses to which it may predispose us.”

Our personality and coping styles reflect the needs of the larger social group in which we develop, says Maté. “The roles we are assigned or denied, how we fit into society or are excluded from it, and what the culture induces us to believe about ourselves, determine much about the health we enjoy or the diseases that plague us.” Illness and health are manifestations of our social macrocosm, he argues.

It’s no surprise, then, that the inequities of society deeply affect our health, with those more politically disempowered or economically disenfranchised being forced to shape and suppress their emotions and needs most gravely to survive, says Maté. This means systemic change to fight inequities and focus on social justice is the foundation of improving our health, a common thread in The Myth of Normal.

At the same time, we can work to unlearn these behaviour patterns by bringing more awareness to our own emotions, signals in our bodies, and our needs, rather than automatically ignoring them in the service of others.

“The personality is an adaptation,” says Maté. “What we call the personality is often a jumble of genuine traits and conditioned coping styles, including some that do not reflect our true self at all but rather the loss of it.”
Maté describes true healing as opening ourselves to the truths of our lives, past and present. “After enough noticing, actual opportunities for choice begin to appear before we betray our true wants and needs,” he says. “We might now find ourselves able to pause in the moment and say, ‘Hmm, I can tell I’m about to stuff down this feeling or thought—is that what I want to do? Is there another option?’

“The emergence of new choices in place of old, preprogrammed dynamics is a sure sign of our authentic selves coming back online.”
Reference :
Psychology today
Link:
https://www.psychologytoday.com/intl/blog/its-not-you-its-the-world/202304/smiling-to-death-the-hidden-dangers-of-being-nice
19 replies
  1. مبینا محمدزاده
    مبینا محمدزاده says:

    it was very useful we have no control over I think this is one of the things we experience and we ignore ourselves for others.I wished the article would offer us more specific ways to have our authentic self back online.

    Reply
  2. Kimiya khoshbin
    Kimiya khoshbin says:

    ‏We learned from childhood that we live only according to society’s standards ‏Telling us not to do it all the time may not be approved by others ‏And suppressing our feelings, emotions and desires is a part of our life ‏Many times when we think we realize that we have thought about everything but ourselves ‏Sometimes we suppress ourselves so much that depression enters our lives

    Reply
  3. کیمیا احمدوند
    کیمیا احمدوند says:

    It can be concluded from this article that we are not responsible for the feelings of others and that we were not born with the personality traits of chronic people and that they have only developed in us. It has nothing to do with will or conscious choice. We are born with developmental traits. We haven’t been, but we can grow and develop it to be accepted. We humans need dependence to survive, and our spirit needs to feel emotions and live based on it.

    Reply
  4. زهرا بابائی
    زهرا بابائی says:

    I wish we could increase our skills to help build self-esteem and self-confidence, so that we can be enough for ourselves and don’t need people’s approval, don’t be afraid of their judgments and move forward stronger.

    Reply
  5. زهرا بابائی
    زهرا بابائی says:

    Most of my comments are about myself. I think it is clear that we are going through many problems. Each of your articles is a piece of the puzzle of our problems, which makes us think deeply. Thank you very much for this effort.

    Reply
  6. fatemeh noorzadeh
    fatemeh noorzadeh says:

    Hello sir,
    I agree with you in all parts.
    In my opinion if you love someone and you don’t want his/her sadness before yourself, at first you should have self confidence, self love , self respect and … then you can focus on others then you can help others. If not, you will just hurt yourself and also after a time the people around you will be hurt.

    Reply
  7. Mobina Mokhtari
    Mobina Mokhtari says:

    Hello dear master,
    it was awesome , I felt great after reading this article. well I believe that you can’t love someone before loving yourself. and accepting yourself with your kindness , anger , anxiety, and all of you feachers is really important because we are all humens and these things aren’t something wierd and we should accept them all. if we hide our feelings and focus on others after some time we will become an ill person that he/she can’t help or even love that person anymore. so even if you love someone, at first love yourself , in this case you can truly love him/her too.

    Reply
  8. Niloofar Nikooie
    Niloofar Nikooie says:

    Dr. Malihi,

    Thank you for sharing this article. I wish “inequities” would be eradicated and that social justice would take its place. However, it seems so far fetched in the short run, at least in developing countries, where governments themselves are the cause of social injustice. I wonder what individuals themselves could do to implement social justice in order to ultimately have a healthier society.

    Reply
  9. Niloofar Nikooie
    Niloofar Nikooie says:

    Such precious points! especially in our passive-aggressive inducer society. I wished the article would offer us more specific ways to have our authentic self back online.

    Reply
  10. fog
    fog says:

    yօu’re really a excellent webmɑster. The web site loading speed is amazing.
    It seems that you are doing any unique trick. Moreover, The contents
    are masterpiece. you havе performed a excellent activity on this topic!

    Reply
  11. hamidreza taheri
    hamidreza taheri says:

    hi dear dr malihi ,
    in my opinion being nice is good but everything is good until you indulgence in it and thats why being nice is not healthy.

    Reply
  12. Maryam farajkhah
    Maryam farajkhah says:

    Hi professor it is not good that we ignore ourselves to pleas others and over time it will cause many angers to accumulate in us.

    Reply
  13. leila asghari asl
    leila asghari asl says:

    Hello, dear teacher, it was very useful, the issues that make a person angry are mostly issues that we have no control over, and the anger accumulates little by little and explodes somewhere, the problem is how to learn to How should we react to issues that are out of our control so that we do not suppress the feeling of anger and solve the issue that caused our anger for ourselves?

    Reply
  14. Setare rezaei
    Setare rezaei says:

    It was a very interesting article, especially as suppressing emotions in a young age than in other periods of life and making it difficult for young people to happen.

    Reply
  15. fateme zare
    fateme zare says:

    Hi dear Master, thank you very much for your article. I think this is one of the things we experience and we ignore ourselves for others. And that’s a lot of damage to us

    Reply
  16. Mahnaz Nouruzi
    Mahnaz Nouruzi says:

    Hello dear professor thank you for sharing this information with us.
    I experienced this subject myself
    In the past I tried to consider other people and I didn’t show my feelings and I got a kind of inflammatory disease

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

20 − 20 =